What if I’d said sorry first? What if I hadn’t gone out that Saturday? What if I’d waited one more week before I said how I felt? You’ve rewritten the ending of your relationship so many times that you could recite every version, and in most of them it works out.
Then morning comes, and the real ending is still the one you’ve got.
Why do I keep asking what if?
Your mind hates unfinished business. When something ends without a proper explanation, or with words left unsaid on both sides, your brain keeps it open like a tab you can’t close. It goes back to it again and again, trying to make it make sense.
The what if questions are your mind’s way of trying to get some control back. If you can find the moment where it went wrong, then surely you could have stopped it, and that feels less frightening than accepting that some of it was never in your hands. The trouble is, there’s no answer at the end of that road. You just go round again.
It’s often far easier to see someone else’s situation clearly than your own. When you hear another person say the thoughts you’ve had at three in the morning, you get a little distance from them. You notice the excuses, the fear and the pride in their story, and then quietly start noticing them in yours.
Pull up a chair
Every Wednesday at seven, two complete strangers meet with me. He and She have different stories, different regrets and very different opinions, but underneath they’re both trying to understand the same thing: what really happened, and why they’re still lying awake over it. This time, you get to listen.
But What If?
A breakup book written as a series of coaching sessions, with nothing rehearsed and almost nothing left unsaid. There are no neat answers or five step plans, just a seat in the room.
Together they explore why someone goes quiet instead of admitting it’s over, the apology he never got and the one she never gave, what “it’s not you, it’s me” might really mean, whether you can ever stay friends with an ex, why seeing your ex move on hurts so much, the ending you keep rewriting in your head, and how to find closure when your ex won’t give it to you.
Some of it will make you laugh. Some of it will make you uncomfortable. Some of it may feel as though someone has been listening to the thoughts you’ve never said out loud.
You don’t need the answer to every what if to move on. Kel x
If there’s one question you can’t stop asking yourself, bring it to a call and we’ll look at it properly, together.
You might also like
As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases.







